Two opinions of international legal experts are missing from the record of the South African Constitutional Court. The Centre on Knowledge Governance is Making them available in this post.
Two opinions of international legal experts are missing from the record of the South African Constitutional Court in Ex parte President of the Republic of South Africa: In re Constitutionality of the Copyright Amendment Bill and the Performers’ Protection Amendment Bill [2026] ZACC.
Judgment in that case was handed down on 26 June 2026, which upheld the constitutionality and international law legality of the fair use exception adopted by Parliament in the Copyright Amendment Bill (CAB), while holding that several sections of the specific exception on educational uses (Sec. 12D) were unconstitutional.
Opposition to the Bill’s fair use proposal included opinions by Dr. Mihály Ficsor and Professor Jane Ginsburg. But researchers at a recent academic conference on the CAB found those opinions missing from the Court’s record. We retrieved each opinion and release them in this post.
Annex “SJHI” – Opinion Prof. J.C. Ginsburg pertaining to the Copyright Amendment Bill dated 18 November 2024.
The opinion was submitted on behalf of several creative industry groups applying to join the case as amici curiae (friends of the court), including CAPASSO, PEN Afrikaans, and the Publishers’ Association of South Africa (PASA). It was originally included in the extensive Digital Record of Referral Part A, from p. 969. But at the time we searched for the record, the Digital Record was not available on the Constitutional Court’s record of the case. In response to a request, the Constitutional Court retrieved the record from its files and delivered it electronically.
The core of the opinion argues that the fair use provision in South Africa’s Copyright Amendment Bill (Section 12A) is different from the fair use provision in U.S. copyright law (17 U.S.C. § 107). Her central conclusion is that South Africa’s proposed Section 12A is broader, vaguer, and less protective of authors and copyright owners than the U.S. fair use doctrine. Some of her arguments include:
• Satire and Pastiche: Unlike U.S. courts, which distinguish parody (which critiques an original work) from satire or mashups (which borrow from a work for humour or general commentary), Section 12A lumps them all together.
• “Education”: Section 12A covers “education” broadly rather than just “teaching.”
• Library/Museum “Access”: Including “access” alongside preservation could be read to allow libraries and museums to digitise and distribute collections.
• “Public Administration”: Allowing uses to ensure the “proper performance of public administration” is broader than the U.S. focus on legislative or judicial proceedings.
View and download the document below.
Answers to Questions concerning the Copyright Amendment Bill and Performers’ Protection Amendment Bill of South Africa by Dr. Mihály Ficsor dated 21 February 2024.
Dr. Ficsor—former Assistant Director General for the Copyright Sector at the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO)—prepared an opinion at the request of an attorney for the PASA shortly before Parliament passed both bills on 29 February 2024. The opinion was later submitted to the Constitutional Court in the case of Blind SA v President of the Republic of South Africa and Others (CCT 300/24) [2025] ZACC 9 (7 May 2025) on behalf of the PASA and other parties opposing Blind SA’s action to declare the Copyright Act unconstitutional to the extent it did not incorporate Section 19 of the CAB into law, which included an exception permitting the creation and exchange of accessible formats of copyright-protected works.
Dr. Ficsor’s opinion was referred to in the later case of In re President, considering the constitutionality of the CAB’s fair use exception and other provisions referred to the Court for review by the President. But the opinion is not included in the record for that case, but is included in the Blind SA case. We retrieved the opinion from that docket and include it here.
Dr. Ficsor’s opinion argues that the US-style “fair use” provision (Section 12A) and educational exceptions (Section 12D)—violate South Africa’s treaty obligations under the Berne Convention and the TRIPS Agreement. It argues that the exceptions are not adequately confined to the international three-step test, which requires that copyright exceptions be for certain special cases, not conflict with a normal exploitation of the work, and not unreasonably prejudice the legitimate interests of rights holders. Ficsor holds this opinion while at the same time concludes that the US fair use exception on which the South Africa law was based is in compliance with the three-step test:
“This is so, because the U.S. fair use doctrine has developed for more than a century before it was codified – although not fully, due to the above-mentioned openness of both the coverage of its reasons and the factors to be considered. At that time, a huge body of case law was already available; it had been clarified in a great number of special cases whether or not there is fair use. Although new issues keep emerging time and again, the existing case law guarantees reasonable legal certainty; the possible new cases may also be solved on the basis of long-developed stable criteria.
…
If Section 12A were adopted in the way it is drafted in the Copyright Amendment Bill, the long-developed case law that in the U.S. is available would be missing in South Africa. Even if it might be considered that the U.S. case law – and the case law of some other countries following the common law legal tradition – could be taken into account to a certain extent. This certainly would take time and would not be a matter of automatism; what may exist elsewhere would have to be adapted to the legal environment and social reality of the country. This in itself would increase uncertainty.”
An extension of this argument that fair use in the US, but not elsewhere, complies with the three-step test by virtue of prior case law was published by Ficsor and Ginsburg in the recent WIPO Guide on International Copyright Treaties. https://legalblogs.wolterskluwer.com/copyright-blog/new-wipo-guide-casts-doubt-on-open-general-exceptions/
View and download the document below.
Promoting Public Access to Legal Records
We release these records as part of the Centre on Knowledge Governance’s commitment to promoting human rights through access to knowledge.
The principle of open justice requires that court proceedings and the records forming part of those proceedings should ordinarily be accessible to the public. This principle is grounded in the South African constitutional values of openness, accountability and transparency, and is reinforced by sections 16(1) and 34 of the Constitution, which protect freedom of expression and the right to a fair public hearing.
In Independent Newspapers (Pty) Ltd v Minister for Intelligence Services [2008] ZACC 6, the Constitutional Court affirmed that the public and the media have a right of access to court proceedings, including the papers and written arguments forming part of those proceedings, subject to legally justified limitations.
In the above Ex parte case, public access to the complete, non-confidential court record is particularly important given the far-reaching implications of the Copyright Amendment Bill and the Performers’ Protection Amendment Bill for copyright law, constitutional rights, and numerous affected stakeholders. Access to all parties’ submissions, amici curiae interventions, expert opinions and supporting documentation enables meaningful public scrutiny of the legal arguments and material placed before the ConCourt.
When the actual court documents are publicly accessible, researchers, legal fraternity and the public can distinguish between what was argued, what evidence was presented and what the Court ultimately decided, rather than relying on media reports, subjective opinions, or selective summaries. It also ensures that the Court’s decision can be properly understood in its full legal context and that an accurate, accessible record is preserved for future legal research, scholarship and public reference.
The restored documents
View and download the documents below.





